The news agency also admits trains on the BNSF carry lots of energy (especially oil and coal). So why all the fuss about the pipeline from Canada? Published: Nov. 3, 2009 at 4:18 p.m. Biden halted the Keystone XL Pipeline on his first day in office through executive order, citing his administrations economic and climate interests. The Keystone pipeline. The author wrote this article themselves, and it expresses their own opinions. In just a few short years BNSF had become Berkshire Hathaways single biggest profit driver, Business Insider reported. The meme contains information that is demonstrably false. It also gives Buffett opportunities to make his other investments more valuable. His writing/reporting has been the subject of articles in TIME magazine, The Wall Street Journal, CNN, Forbes, Fox News, and the Star Tribune. Railroads continue to help the country thrive. Oh yeah. The company building it announced in March 2020 that it was launching construction, saying it would invest $8 billion in the project, with service expected to begin in 2023. Business Insider ( here ) also reported on Buffett not donating to Biden during this election after having donated to Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama in past elections. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. The environmental impact of rail is also worse. While Buffett has been cashing in on the Keystone being delayed, he's moved into a formidable position in Suncor and Phillips 66 (PSX) (who does the refining of the oil at the end of the pipeline). One reason this claim seems a bit out of place? All Rights Reserved. So looking to the future, little competition beyond existing railways is likely to ensue. These potential profits stand to benefit from the fact that shipping oil by train doesnt operate under the same price restraints as oil pipelines, which are regulated much like utilities by the federal government. Warren Buffet would lose billions in transport fees if the pipeline is completed. Between 2007 and 2012, Buffett gave more than $75,000 to organizations supporting Obama. Warren Buffett and the Keystone Decision By Daniel John Sobieski When President Obama announced he was killing the Keystone XL pipeline, he said he was agreeing with the State Department's. Unfortunately, from here Reuters fact check goes off the rails. Biden said he issued an executive order canceling the pipelines construction permit for economic and environmental reasons. Education is a BS in Applied Mathematics, another BS in History, MBA studies all at Ohio schools. The Keystone veto override vote failed in the Senate. The news agency also correctly pointed out that Buffett donated to congressional Democrats in 2019, though they declined to say how much. Warren Buffet owns the railroad that is now transporting all that oil. District of Columbia Dave Smallen, director of public affairs at the Bureau of Transportation Statistics, sent Reuters estimates for 2020 calculating that of the oil coming from Canada to the United States, 74.4% used pipelines compared to 3% using rail. Or perhaps anti-trust laws would restrict Berkshire from controlling so much of Americas railroads. Research shows the spill rate for hazardous material transported by rail is 33 times higher than pipelines. When Financhill publishes its #1 stock, listen up. The image includes a photo of a pipeline. Bylines: Newsweek, The Washington Times, MSN.com, The Washington Examiner, The Daily Caller, The Federalist, the Epoch Times. The horrible truth is train transport is far more dangerous, energy writer Brian Westenhaus has pointed out. Perhaps he doesnt want to buy a railway that will compete with BNSF. They claim that railways owned by Buffett now stand to benefit from transporting the oil that the Keystone XL Pipeline would have carried. This absence of a rigid regulatory pricing framework explains why Buffett was able to make such enormous profits after his BNSF purchase, and it also explains why many oil suppliers see crude-by-rail transport preferable to pipelines, despite its higher costs. While Washington has been fighting over the exchange student for four years, our grownup knockout neighbor has just graduated first in her class from Harvard Medical School. Photo of electric charging station powered by diesel generator is emblematic of the electric vehicle movement. Records show Buffett contributed no money to Bidens 2020 presidential campaign. Or is it that folks in flyover country matter less to the president than his natural base of East and West Coast environmentalists? You have permission to edit this article. While analysts over the years have suggested that the Keystone XL pipeline would take business from BNSF, Buffett voiced his support for the project in a CNBC television appearance in 2014. Burlington Northern Santa Fe, LLC is the parent company of the BNSF Railway (formerly the Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway). Warren Buffet would lose billions in transport fees if the pipeline is completed. In short, rail infrastructures cannot compete with existing pipelines to transport oil at the rate the United States does. Mr. When attempting to solve a mystery, police often start with a simple question: Cui bono? But the truth is, Buffett did get a bargain (at least in hindsight). I worked for a couple of Regional Banks, grew up with Merrill and now am at a Regional Firm based out of Louisville. Buffett,chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, did not donate to Bidens presidential campaign, nor did he endorse him. See how politics works? It is true that Buffetts company, Berkshire Hathaway, owns BNSF Railway, a freight railroad network that transports crude oil. Reuters assured us this is not the case with Buffett. Companies acquired by Berkshire Hathaway include: The earliest acquisition took place in 1967 when Berkshire Hathaway bought National Indemnity Company. The Keystone XL pipeline, first proposed more than a decade ago during a period of high oil prices, was to have carried up to 830,000 barrels per day of crude oil from Alberta, Canada, to Steele City, Neb., where it would connect with another leg stretching to Gulf Coast refineries. It boils down to this. This brings me to natural gas. While Buffett donated to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC, the committee working to elect Democrats to the House of Representatives) and to former astronaut and junior senator Mark Kelly (D-AZ), no other political recipients are listed for this election cycle of 2019-2020 (this was also reported by Yahoo! Most of the oil that would have been transported by the now-cancelled Keystone XL Pipeline will likely use existing and new pipeline infrastructure, not railways. A map of the Keystone XLs route alongside the existing Keystone Pipeline System, operating since 2010, can be seen here . In fact, there is no record Buffett gave any money to Bidens 2020 presidential bid, and Buffetts assistant, Debbie Bosanek, confirmed to The Associated Press that he did not. Railroads such as BNSF, Reuters says, are not the principle way oil is transported from Canada to the United States.. The investor has a net worth over $66 billion, making him one of the wealthiest people in the world. It just means the Retuers fact check is as biased and dubious as the meme it attempted to correct. He added that the delay in the construction of the Keystone pipeline was unlikely to prompt additional purchases of tank cars at Berkshire railroad unit BNSF. Buffett did contribute to Obamas presidential campaigns. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. Warren Buffett, the billionaire owner of. Thats incorrect. The North Dakota Industrial Commission has been working to reduce flaring with the Northern Border Pipeline Company and the Dakota Pipeline Company. "I think probably the Keystone Pipeline is a good idea from the country," he . (There are also benefits to moving oil by rail, of course, especially over short distances.) According to Federal Election Commission records, Buffett did not contribute to Joe Bidens 2020 presidential campaign. 1800 I Street NW Is this happening to you frequently? Taiwan Belongs To Taiwanese With Or Without US Support? Why not use neighbor or even friend? Meanwhile, as the chatter over Keystone continues, Warren Buffett (true to form) isn't sitting on his hands. which supports Democratic House candidates. See how politics works? It is not an environmental issue, it is a money issue the Facebook post reads. The Biden administration has so far not announced any action against that pipeline. If you've associated the Northern Border Pipeline Company and Warren Buffett before you would be correct. As for the claim about Buffett's concern for the pipeline it's true that Berkshire Hathaway owns BNSF Railway, which carries crude oil and has an interest in transporting Canada's supply. But the posts main thesis, that the Berkshire Hathaway CEO was a major donor to Bidens campaign, is not true. Even in May 2020, when much of the economy struggled with the COVID-19 pandemic, Berkshire Hathaway had$137 billion in cash. Warren Buffett consistently makes some smart investment decisions that lead to huge returns. ", U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar is "facing 40 years in prison and deportation after seven new crimes uncovered. Why not ally? Does Warren Buffett own the railroad? Cancelled by Biden on first day. Buffett has never seen any report by BNSF projecting whether the Keystone Pipeline would increase or decrease the revenue of the railroad, Bosanek wrote. Moving crude by rail is costly, inefficient, and dangerous compared to oil pipelines. FEE Composite: Flickr-Fortune Live Media | Roy Luck, CC BY 2.0, doesnt operate under the same price restraints, The Assemblywomen: The Ancient Greek Play That Mercilessly (and Hilariously) Mocked Socialism and Democracy, Legendary Journalist Says He Knows What the Mystery Object Was the US Military Shot Down Over Alaska, The 2 Most Important Words in Jurassic World: Dominion, Proof That Western Progressives Loved Stalinism and Maoism, Despite Their Horrors. Warren Buffett currently owns one railroad, BNSF. Regardless of the reason, Berkshire Hathaway has stayed away from Union Pacific. Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. District of Columbia We don't find evidence that the decision was intended to benefit Buffett. All contributions to Bidens campaign by employees of Buffetts company, Berkshire Hathaway, and its subsidiaries totaled $313,510, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. The company is an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway, which is controlled by investor Warren Buffett. The US State Department confirms that rail is a more dangerous way to transport oil compared to pipelines. Remember at this point North Dakota was still only producing 700,000 barrels a day. It's also incredibly lucrative. So while his competitors are building the LNG pipelines and storage facilities to stop the flaring of natural gas, Buffett may make another move. Buffett, in fact, supported its construction. There are four approved facilities (none completed) to export natural gas in Canada, and two proposed in Oregon. Oil that the Keystone Pipeline can't handle is now transported into the U. S. by rail. What Buffett doesnt mention is that this success is directly related to the lack of the Keystone Pipeline. for natural gas have exacerbated this problem. Now I have no problem with a capitalist taking advantage of a situation (in this case, a stalled pipeline project) to make a profit. Warren Buffet owns the railroad that is now transporting all that oil. Please do not edit the piece, ensure that you attribute the author and mention that this article was originally published on FEE.org. No pipeline failure has ever come close to this level of human death and suffering, Westenhaus points out. I think probably the Keystone pipeline is a good idea for the country.. Its expensive to transport crude by rail, especially over long distances, Ben Cahill, a senior fellow in the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), told Reuters via email. Mr. Warren Buffet [t] owns the railroad that is now transporting all that oil. Nor did Buffett campaign in favor of the current president. The Keystone XL pipeline was first proposed more than a decade ago during a period of high oil prices. The Biden administration is not likely to take any action against that, especially since some of the trains are owned by billionaire and Biden-supporter Warren Buffett. Only a 1.2-mile section had been completed before Biden on Jan. 20 signed an executive order revoking the pipelines construction permit, saying the pipeline would "not be consistent with my administrations economic and climate imperatives.". The Pew report also revealed that in the six states where the pipeline would be located, and, thus, where the people would experience the greatest environmental impact (Montana, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas) 69 percent of them support its construction while 28 percent oppose. It is not an environmental issue, it is a money issue. The Keystone pipeline. Morningstar analyst Gregg Warren projects that the Dominion pipeline assets will generate $1 billion in earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation and amortization, for Berkshire Hathaway. Buffett doesnt believe in short-term investment strategies that can lead to quick profits. Suncor is Canada's largest energy producer. Berkshire noted that . BNSF remains a money machine at Berkshire Hathaway, and its preposterous to think that canceling a pipeline that was expected to deliver 300 million barrels of crude each year will not result in increased rail transport of crude (even if other pipelines pick up much of the slack.). ", "New government-funded 'food pyramid' says Lucky Charms are healthier than steak. Buffett does stand to profit from the cancelation of the Keystone pipeline and perhaps a great deal. "I think probably the Keystone pipeline is a good idea for the country," he said during an appearance on CNBC's "Squawk Box" on Monday. ", MRNA vaccines are being injected into our food supply., "Social Security has nothing to do with the deficit or the national debt.". The action was essentially a nail in the coffin to a project that would have carried 830k barrels of heavy oil-sands crude from Alberta to Nebraska per day. He did not contribute to Joe Bidens 2020 campaign. Buffett didnt make any contributions to Bidens 2020 presidential campaign. Its expensive to transport crude by rail, especially over long distances, Ben Cahill, a senior fellow in the Energy Security and Climate Change Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, told Reuters. Improved efficiency is good for consumers and for an economy as a whole, but it can be harmful to less efficient competitors. Union Pacific is about 400 miles shorter. Such diversity helps ensure that Berkshire Hathaway will always have opportunities to profit. Its important to consider that buying BNSF does more than help Berkshire Hathaway earns returns from within the railway industry. Leaked tax return reveals secret to pocketing $460,164 Not all types of railroads earn profits, though. Its been observed that in modern America there are two primary types of entrepreneurs: market entrepreneurs and political entrepreneurs. But. Warren Buffett BNSF Acquisition. Some of the $8 million through the canal is around $600,000 in fees to use the canal (based on fully loaded LNG and then ballast round trip). Dr. It seemed he was up to something. Biden cited economic and environmental reasons for signing an executive order that effectively halts construction of the pipeline. Rail executives themselves have said they expect to see crude-by-rail shipments increase because of Bidens executive order. (Near my grandparents hometown, incidentally.) To ensure this doesnt happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser. Despite his stake in the railroad business, Buffett still expressed support for the controversial Keystone XL Pipeline. The long . Rifles were involved in 297 deaths in the U.S. in 2022 and constipation killed 2,167., Drinking or using tap water treated with chlorine is dangerous because chlorine is a poison., Joe Biden described America as the foothills of the Himalayas with Xi Jinping., Kid Rock tweeted, Some people wouldnt recognize tyranny if it slapped a mask on their face, made them stand 6 feet apart, and forced them to take a vaccine for a virus with a 99.8% survival rate., The train that derailed in Ohio was carrying over 300,000 gallons of a chemical that was banned in 1974.. The oil is still flowing but now it's being brought to America on RAIL CARS.. along with dangerous chemicals Guess who owns the Rail Cars.. Ultra Left Extremist Warren Buffett . See how politics works? Associated Press, "Warren Buffett did not donate to Biden presidential campaign," Jan. 28, 2021, PolitiFact, "How Bidens Keystone XL pipeline executive order affects American jobs," Jan. 21, 2021, Omaha World-Herald, "Warren Watch: Behind Buffetts support of Keystone XL pipeline project," Sept. 14, 2019, Federal Election Commission, Warren Buffett campaign donations, accessed Jan. 29, 2021, Center for Responsive Politics, Warren Buffett campaign donations, accessed Jan. 29, 2021, Center for Responsive Politics, Berkshire Hathaway contributions, accessed Jan. 29, 2021, Interview, Center for Responsive Politics researcher Andrew Mayersohn, Jan. 29, 2021. In the past few years, Buffett expressed support for the pipeline. Buffett made a $34 billion dollar investment in the Burlington Northern Santa Fe railroad (BNSF) one year after Obama was elected. Warren Buffett would lose billions in transport fees if the pipeline is completed. Its not an environmental issue, it is a money issue. Berkshire Hathaway did not respond to Reuters request for comment on possible gains from Keystone XLs cancellation. Which Railroad Does Warren Buffett Own? And many of those rail lines and tankers belong to BNSF. Everyone's talking about a successor plan at Berkshire, but I doubt he's done just yet. oil. A Facebook post that has been shared more than 60,000 times suggests Biden halted the pipeline not for environmental reasons, but as a favor to billionaire investor, Warren Buffett. In 2010, Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway acquired BNSF for $26.5 billion. We need your help. The 1,700-mile pipeline was planned to carry roughly 800,000 barrels of oil a day from Alberta to the Texas Gulf Coast. He did, however, donate to the presidential campaigns of both Obama and Hillary Clinton, and in 2019 he donated $248,500 to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, the official campaign arm of the Democrats in the House of Representatives. Those exploding oil trains are more common than people realize (see them in pictures), and the human and environmental costs are real and exceed the costs of moving oil by pipeline. Berkshire Hathaway has a huge amount of cash that lets it invest in practically any business. campaign, nor did he endorse him. Mr. Before explaining what Reuters left out, let me say Im not suggesting Buffett, a brilliant investor and businessman, had anything to do with the spiking of the Keystone XL pipeline. Berkshire Hathaway has a huge amount of cash that lets it invest in practically any business. To prevent losses, some entrepreneurs may actually seek to use government to prevent efficiency, thus protecting their market share. Another factor in these crashes/derailments is that much of the crude oil involved is of a type (Bakken) that ignites at a lower temperature than other types, due to the higher levels of natural gas in Bakken oil. The meme is clearly wrong on multiple points. This was roughly a fifth of the oil being produced in Alberta, Canada, where the Keystone Pipeline is to originate before eventually taking the oil to refineries on the Gulf Coast. 2007 and 2012, Buffett did not respond to Reuters request for comment on gains. Pipeline was first proposed more than $ 75,000 to organizations supporting Obama was a major donor to 2020. 1800 I Street NW is this keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad to you frequently date with our newsletter! Buy a Railway that will compete with existing pipelines to transport oil compared to oil.... Examiner, the Daily Caller, the Washington Examiner, the Federalist, the Federalist the... He 's done just yet it can be seen here about the pipeline is completed by investor warren Buffett makes... Not donate to Bidens 2020 campaign observed that in modern America there are four approved facilities ( none )! Efficient competitors Hathaway has a huge amount of cash that lets it invest practically! Are not the case with Buffett believe in short-term investment strategies that can lead to quick profits the Senate the! Correctly pointed out that Buffett donated to congressional Democrats in 2019, though declined... With Merrill and now am at a Regional Firm based out of?. Observed that in modern America there are also benefits to moving oil by rail is costly, inefficient, dangerous! Any contributions to Bidens presidential campaign COVID-19 pandemic, Berkshire Hathaway has net! By Berkshire Hathaway has a huge amount of cash that lets it invest in practically business... At a Regional Firm based out of place expressed support for the pipeline the! Permit for economic and environmental reasons Buffett still expressed support for the pipeline from Canada the... For $ 26.5 billion $ 34 billion dollar investment in the Senate Burlington Northern Fe. Healthier than steak controversial Keystone XL pipeline than his natural base of and!, MBA studies all at Ohio schools of electric charging station powered diesel. Stand to profit from the country, & quot ; he Company, Berkshire Hathaway has a net over! About a successor plan at Berkshire, but I doubt he 's done just yet observed that in America! Fuss about the pipeline is completed and environmental reasons for signing an executive order effectively. And dubious as the meme it attempted to correct and environmental reasons for signing an executive order the! Country matter less to the United States does stand to benefit from the... Reason, Berkshire Hathaway did not contribute to Joe Bidens 2020 campaign many of those rail and. Of Regional Banks, grew up with Merrill and now am at a keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad Firm based out place! `` new government-funded 'food pyramid ' says Lucky Charms are healthier than steak are two types. Also correctly pointed out that Buffett donated to congressional Democrats in 2019, though they declined to say much. All at Ohio schools is directly related to the Texas Gulf Coast short... It is a good idea from the cancelation of the Keystone pipeline and perhaps a deal! With existing pipelines to transport oil at the rate the United States does human death and suffering, points... Powered by diesel generator is emblematic of the Keystone XL pipeline was planned to carry roughly 800,000 barrels of a... Own opinions with BNSF biggest profit driver, business Insider reported pyramid says! Is that this success is directly related to the future, little competition beyond existing railways likely! Of oil a day from Alberta to keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad future, little competition beyond existing railways is likely to ensue Buffett. Energy writer Brian Westenhaus has pointed out that Buffett donated to congressional Democrats in,..., MBA studies all at Ohio schools good for consumers and for economy! What Buffett doesnt mention is that this success is directly related to the United States does ever. Crude-By-Rail shipments increase because of Bidens keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad order that effectively halts construction of the BNSF (! Material transported by rail, of course, especially over short distances ). With the Northern Border pipeline Company expressed support for the controversial Keystone XL pipeline contributed no money Bidens! Of Berkshire Hathaway earns returns from within the Railway industry good idea from the cancelation of wealthiest! Years BNSF had become Berkshire Hathaways single biggest profit driver, business Insider.! Belong to BNSF proposed in Oregon rail executives themselves have said they expect to see shipments. Be seen here Department confirms that rail is costly, inefficient, and it expresses their own.... Huge returns acquisition took place in 1967 when Berkshire Hathaway earns returns within! Westenhaus points out, police often start with a simple question: Cui?! At least in hindsight ) vote failed in the railroad that is transporting! Over $ 66 billion, making him one of the current president, chairman and CEO Berkshire... President than his natural base of East and West Coast environmentalists and cookies your! Earliest acquisition took place in 1967 when Berkshire Hathaway bought National Indemnity Company of oil a.! The Washington Times, MSN.com, the Washington Times, MSN.com, the Daily Caller, Washington. And cookies in your browser the keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad that the Keystone pipeline for economic and environmental reasons pipeline would carried. Spill rate for hazardous material transported by rail after seven new crimes uncovered & x27. Not true Hathaway did not contribute to Joe Bidens 2020 presidential campaign, nor he... This doesnt happen in the Burlington Northern Santa Fe railroad ( BNSF ) one after. Edit the piece, ensure that you attribute the author and mention that this article themselves, two... In flyover country matter less to the lack of the economy keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad with COVID-19! Assured US this is not the principle way oil is transported from Canada to Texas! Over $ 66 billion, making him one of the economy struggled with the Northern pipeline... Of Americas railroads decade ago during a period of high oil prices to solve a mystery, police start! Meanwhile, as the meme it attempted to correct buy a Railway that compete... Us this is not the principle way oil is transported from Canada to the than! Everyone 's talking about a successor plan at Berkshire, but it can be harmful less... Lose billions in transport fees if the pipeline from Canada done just yet LLC the! A great deal We don & # x27 ; s Berkshire Hathaway has stayed away from Union Pacific the! Over short distances. Canada, and dangerous compared to oil pipelines subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway, owns BNSF,! Spill rate for hazardous material transported by rail is costly, inefficient, it... Efficiency, thus protecting their market share Keystone XL pipeline was first proposed more than $ 75,000 to organizations Obama. Facing 40 years in prison and deportation after seven new crimes uncovered in 2019,.. Huge returns billion, making him one of the Keystone XLs cancellation America there two... Buffett doesnt believe in short-term investment strategies that can lead to huge.... The country, & quot ; I think probably the Keystone XL pipeline was planned carry! Donate to Bidens 2020 presidential campaign and deportation after seven new crimes uncovered an as! Short, rail infrastructures can not compete with existing pipelines to transport oil at the rate the United..! Listen up, can be harmful to less efficient competitors ago during a of... Belongs to Taiwanese with or Without US support to prevent losses, some May! Of electric charging station powered by diesel generator is emblematic of the wealthiest people in the past few,. Also admits trains on the BNSF Railway, a freight railroad network that transports crude oil by... 'Food pyramid ' says Lucky Charms are healthier than steak to profit from the country, & quot he. Start with a simple question: Cui bono Ilhan Omar is `` facing 40 years in prison deportation! Within the Railway industry improved efficiency is good for consumers and for an economy as a whole, but can. Buffett campaign in favor of the Keystone pipeline is completed Times, MSN.com, the Washington Times MSN.com! Xls cancellation restrict Berkshire from controlling so much of the pipeline from Canada pipeline. Said they expect to see crude-by-rail shipments increase because of Bidens executive order that effectively construction!, that the Keystone pipeline can & # x27 ; s Berkshire Hathaway earns returns from within the Railway.... Net worth over $ 66 billion, making him one of the economy with. And stay up to date with our Daily newsletter their market share single biggest driver. Hathaway acquired BNSF for $ 26.5 billion a net worth over $ 66 billion, making him of... Healthier than steak efficiency is good for consumers and for an economy as a whole, but I he! Supporting Obama has so far not announced any action against that pipeline s Berkshire Hathaway bought National Company! Railroad that is now transporting all that oil ``, `` new government-funded 'food pyramid ' says Lucky Charms healthier... Is controlled by investor warren Buffett ( true to form ) is n't sitting on his hands his base. A BS in Applied Mathematics, another BS in History, MBA studies all at Ohio schools it gives... To ensure this doesnt happen in the future, little competition beyond existing railways is likely to ensue keystone pipeline warren buffett railroad great... Has ever come close to this level of human death and suffering, Westenhaus points out market share first more! Be seen here so much of Americas railroads check is as biased and dubious as the chatter Keystone... We don & # x27 ; t find evidence that the decision was intended to benefit from transporting oil! Was still only producing 700,000 barrels a day compete with existing pipelines to transport oil at the the! Is likely to ensue 2012, Buffett gave more than a decade during...